Skeptic: Examining Extraordinary Claims and Promoting Science Skeptic: Examining Extraordinary Claims and Promoting Science

top navigation:

Wednesday, March 26th, 2014 | ISSN 1556-5696

eSkeptic: the email newsletter of the Skeptics Society

Share this eSkeptic with friends online. Subscribe | Donate | Watch Lectures | Shop


The Amazing Meeting 2014, July 10-13, South Point Casino, Las Vegas

Join Us For The Amazing Meeting
South Point Casino, Las Vegas
July 10–13, 2014

How does cognitive science inform the project of skepticism? What brain sciences should you be skeptical about? Are brains hard-wired for belief in the unbelievable? Explore the science of the brain at The Amazing Meeting 2014: the world’s largest celebration of science and skepticism!

Our theme this year—Skepticism & The Brain—focusses on the cognitive and brain sciences and how they inform the project of skepticism. Keynote speakers include the acclaimed philosopher, cognitive scientist, and best selling author DANIEL DENNETT, Scientific American Editor-in-Chief MARIETTE DICHRISTINA, and MICHAEL SHERMER, Editor-in-Chief of Skeptic magazine. Other speakers include neurophilosopher Patricia Churchland, Australia’s Dr. Karl, Evolution & Human Behavior Editor-in-Chief Robert Kurzban, Brainwashed: The Seductive Appeal of Mindless Neuroscience authors Scott Lilienfeld and Sally Satel, M.D., influential memory researcher Elizabeth Loftus, clinical neurologist Steven Novella, M.D., immunologist Paul Offit, M.D., National Center for Science Education’s Eugenie Scott, psychologists and best selling authors Carol Tavris and Richard Wiseman, and many, many more!

This annual celebration of critical thinking is an unparalleled opportunity to make like-minded friends, enjoy some of the brightest minds on issues important to skeptics, and leave with tools for spreading a helpful and educational message to those who might be hurt by charlatans and unfounded belief. Join James Randi and over a thousand other like-minded folks for four days of fun, friendship, and critical thinking!

Enter “SKEPTICMAGAZINE” when registering and save $25.

Register for TAM today!


The Unbelievers

Richard Dawkins & Lawrence Krauss screen The Unbelievers

New York Times bestselling author Richard Dawkins will tour the United States in April to screen his new film, The Unbelievers, and answer audience questions. The evolutionary biologist is joined by internationally known physicist Lawrence Krauss, and at one stop by magician Penn Jillette of Penn & Teller. Filmmakers Gus Holwerda and Luke Holwerda of Black Chalk Productions will also appear and take questions. The film is a road trip documentary that follows Dawkins and Krauss as they make stops around the world, from Australia to New York, to speak out for reason and science. “One of the most remarkable things about making The Unbelievers,” said Gus Holwerda, “was to reveal the Richard Dawkins that you don’t see in public life. He can be a bulldog at the podium when it comes to defending science and reason, but in the film we see him for the person he is, extremely warm and personable.” Several celebrities appear in the film to support Dawkins and Krauss on their journey to promote reason and science, including Woody Allen, Stephen Hawking, Stephen Colbert, Cameron Diaz, Sarah Silverman, Bill Pullman, Werner Herzog, and Bill Maher. The movie ends with The Reason Rally: the largest atheist rally in history that took place in Washington DC in 2012.

Tour Dates

April 2, 2014, at 6:00 p.m.
The UC San Diego RIMAC
9500 Gilman Dr., La Jolla, CA
Order tickets

April 3, 2014, at 7:30 p.m.
The Cox Pavilion at the University of Nevada
4505 S Maryland Pkwy, Las Vegas, NV
Hosted by magician Penn Jillette of Penn & Teller
Order tickets

April 7, 2014, at 7:00 p.m.
Mershon Auditorium at the Ohio State University
1871 N. High Street, Columbus, OH
Order tickets

See the film and join the conversation in person with Richard Dawkins, Lawrence Krauss, and the filmmakers. For more information, visit RichardDawkins.net or UnbelieversMovie.com.
Follow The Unbelievers on Twitter @unbelieversfilm.


Yoda

This is a screenshot of Yoda from the copyrighted Star Wars movie series (found on the Star Wars Wiki: Wookieepedia). It is used here under the fair use provision of United States copyright law to identify the character being discussed in the following article.

About this week’s eSkeptic

In this week’s eSkeptic, we present Andrew Harter’s case for the existence of Yoda, which appeared in Skeptic magazine issue 6.3 (1998).

Andrew Mayne (formerly Harter) is the star of A&E’s magic reality show Don’t Trust Andrew Mayne. His novel, Angel Killer, available in paperback from Bourbon Street Books (September 2014) was the fifth best-selling independent release in the United Kingdom in 2012. With the support of the James Randi Educational Foundation, Mayne started a program using magic to teach critical thinking skills in public schools, and his Wizard School segments aired nationwide on Public Television.

Share this article with friends online.
Subscribe | Donate | Watch Lectures | Shop

The Case for Yoda

by Andrew Harter

The recent coverage in Skeptic of ‘The God Question” (Skeptic 5.2) and the following article “The Case for God” (Skeptic 6.2) was quite interesting— yet a bit one sided. I feel that it unfairly neglected the debate over another supernatural entity—Yoda, the little green Jedi master who first appeared in The Empire Strikes Back. Cynics will immediately dismiss the suggestion that the existence of Yoda be seriously debated because he is clearly a fictional creation. However I propose that his apparent origin in the mind of George Lucas is actually further proof of his supernatural nature and all the more reason to bring the debate over Yoda to the skeptical forefront.

Yodists, those that believe in the existence of Yoda, and Atheiyodists, those that don’t (also sometimes called Trekkies), are divided into two very different world views. Yodists accept that the universe is guided by an all-encompassing energy that connects every living thing and every object. We’ll call this mystical force the “Force.” Yodists accept the idea that the Force works in strange and unimaginable ways. It guides us and controls us while giving us the power to choose between good and evil (the dark side of the Force.) Yoda is the greatest teacher there ever was of the ways of the Force. Atheiyodists deny Yoda because they are cruel, pessimistic people who have trouble accepting the wisdom of a short, green, big-eared entity that is so much more wise than they.

The first argument the Atheiyodists use in the debate over the existence of Yoda is that he is an imaginary character. They claim his origin as fictitious creation by director George Lucas, the alleged creator of all the characters in the Star Wars universe, is a widely accepted fact. However, what they are forgetting is that Yodists don’t dispute this. Yodists accept that George Lucas was the first person to “see” Yoda and to bring him to our attention. What the Atheiyodists are missing is that this was simply the way in which Yoda chose to reveal himself to us. By doing it in this manner he has given us a choice. We can merely believe that he is a puppet given life by the imagination of George Lucas and the voice of Frank Oz—or we can accept the greater truth that there always has been and always will be a Yoda who is all knowing and all powerful. Yoda used the cinematic experience to give us the opportunity to allow us the choice between Yodism and Atheiyodism.

While intense meditation has revealed to me all the proof I need, there are other examples that prove the case for Yoda. What would have happened if had Yoda appeared in any other movie than the Academy Award winning blockbuster The Empire Strikes Back? What if humans never developed the sense of sight or hearing? The Anthroyodic Principle shows us that if any of the conditions were just slightly off, there never could have been a Yoda for us to appreciate. The truth is that Yoda created these conditions so that we could learn from his wisdom in just the right atmosphere. The fact that in the movie he lives on a planet called Dagobah in a galaxy far, far away, is his way of telling us that even if conditions had been wildly different he still could have appeared to us—because he’s all powerful. Imagine if the principles of physics were slightly different and movie projectors were an impossibility? Or the physics was right but nobody ever bothered to invent a movie projector? What Atheiyodists would call “coincidences” a Yodist or any other reasonable person would admit was a miracle.

Atheiyodists are found of showing production stills and behind the scenes footage of The Empire Strikes Back and The Return Of The Jedi that show a Yoda puppet sitting lifelessly on a work bench or being animated by a person under a set. They say that this is proof that he is less than divine. What they haven’t let themselves appreciate is the fact that this is merely part of his plan. Yoda allows us to believe that he is merely a creation of Latex and foam rubber so that we can have the choice to believe. For those that want to live their lives spiritually bereft of the wisdom of Yoda, they can ignore the fact that on the screen the Latex and foam rubber transcend into something more spectacular. He becomes a living breathing being filled with the wisdom of the ages. This they cannot explain. Nor can the Atheiyodists tell us how it is that in a matter of a few months more people knew the name of Yoda and were touched by his wisdom than by any other spiritual figure in the history of mankind.

For further proof of Yoda I cite the near-tragic car accident that George Lucas was involved in when he was a young man. What kills thousands of other people every year left Lucas alive. He had a reputation for driving fast and recklessly, yet he survived it all. This incident, which reasonably could have been expected to take his life, in fact served as a catalyst for him to decide to devote his life to making movies. Yet, Yoda has a plan and we are all part of it. He chose to intervene so that Lucas could serve as his conduit.

I have meditated deeply and felt the way of the Force coursing through me. I have come to the understanding that Yoda is very real and a part of my life. Atheiyodists would do well to dispense with their prejudices and open themselves to the insights that come from within. Granted that these insights are very often flawed and that society never made any real advances until it began testing theories in the laboratory of the real world instead of the limited one in our heads. Obviously George Lucas’s survival can be looked upon as just the results of sheer probability. And yes, I admit that the Anthroyodic Principal is a rather silly argument and circular in nature because it takes for granted that we could no more argue our existence if we did not exist than a dead Christian Scientist can give testimony. But all of that doesn’t matter because when I close my eyes and reach my special place and ask the question “Yoda, are you there?” I hear a strange little voice that says “Yes, it is I that is here.” Yes, it is Yoda that is here. Away put your skepticism. END


Marc Rayman, on Vimeo On Demand
NASA’s Dawn Mission to the Asteroid Belt

Marc Rayman

The ambitious Dawn mission, launched in September 2007, is one of NASA’s most remarkable ventures into the solar system. The spacecraft has recently completed a spectacular exploration of Vesta and is now traveling to Ceres; these were among the last uncharted worlds in the inner solar system prior to Dawn. Remnants from the time that planets were formed, Ceres and Vesta hold clues that will help scientists understand the dawn of the solar system. Dawn is the only spacecraft ever to orbit an object in the asteroid belt. Such a mission would be impossible without the use of ion propulsion, a technology that has mostly been in the domain of science fiction, but which was tested extensively on the Deep Space 1 mission, paving the way for Dawn. Dr. Marc Rayman, Dawn’s Chief Engineer and Mission Director at JPL, will describe the Dawn mission and its use of ion propulsion as well as its two exotic destinations. He will also share the excitement and profundity of controlling a spacecraft in deep space.

Rent this video for $3.95 for a 72-hour period.

Rent this video for only $3.95
or explore the entire series.

INSTRUCTIONS: Click the button above, then click the RENT ONE button on the page that will open in your Internet browser. You will then be asked to login to your Vimeo account (or create a free account). Once you complete your purchase of the video rental, you will then be able to instantly stream the video to your computer, smartphone, or tablet, and watch it for the rental period. Videos play best on Vimeo when you allow the entire video to buffer before viewing it.

11 Comments »

11 Comments

  1. dennis trimble says:

    There is nothing new or magic about Yoda, he (it?) is ‘borrowed’ like other characters in Lucas’ work. If you want to learn where the story line came from read the “Diamond Sutra” and all will be revealed. Much of Lucas work (viewed by some as slapstick
    superbly executed) is a tribute to some older work he admires. He and his cadre of advisors / collaborators (the Jedi?) conspire to put together a series of scenes cribbed from earlier works. I think of most of them as a tribute to some long gone heroic producer rather than plagiarism.

    One character that haunts me is Dexter Jettster; I know I saw a scene in an old movie wherein a shamus visits a nearly identical character for advice in solving a crime. Hopefully some reader will remember the movie and enlighten me. Meanwhile I will retreat to the Oasis of Jedda and contemplate the wonders of the hidden forces which govern the Universe.

    Dennis Trimble

  2. C Glenn says:

    That’s funny, whenever I close my eyes and ask if he is there, he says “Always here I am”. You must be from a heretical sect.

    • Bob Pease says:

      Actually, “Here always am”

      is better..
      The peculiar part is that it is really just a dramatic device for
      Yoda not to be able to use correct grammar, but it is
      somehow handled in the same manner as Mr. Data in Star Trek.
      something like

      “I cannot use contractions because my programmer programmed
      me this way. I do not particularly approve of the impression that this gives of me”

      RJP

  3. Bob Pease says:

    “Yodists accept that the universe is guided by an all-encompassing energy that connects every living thing and every object. We’ll call this mystical force the “Force.” ”

    NewAgers accept that the universe is guided by an all-encompassing energy that connects every living thing and every object. We’ll call this mystical force the “CHI.”

    A horse by any other name still smells as puck

    Maybe Star Wars is supposed to be a satire of Magickal Thinking, but
    I think most folks don’t get the humor if intended.

    Actually , my point is that the “article” for today is a clear demonstration of Pease’s Second Law
    ” an attempt at parody can only be successful if exceeds a recognizable limit absurdity”

    Dr. Sidethink Hp.D

  4. Jay says:

    A Yodist I am, and always will be. The Yodiological argument developed in this article is sound -George Lucas is indeed the Prophet of the One Eternal Truth. What we must do is Spread the Word. And, of course, get it to be taught in school. It is NOT gravity that makes apples fall from trees to the ground instead of disappearing in the clouds. It is the Force. Force theory and physics are equally valid. We Yodists may be wrong, that’s granted. I know we aren’t, but others have the right to disagree. Students have the inalienable right to be told that there is more than one explanation for such phenomena. We absolutely must teach the dabate. We have a responsibilty, a sacred trust. If there is one thing we mustn’t do, it’s narrow their view. And schools all over the world, in their “Science” classes, are doing so as to the hotly contested question of so-called “gravity”. Science education must be about the real world and the forces governing it, about making young people, the future of the world, think. We just can’t allow it to be used to teach uncritically accepted dogma. If there is a debate raging, if there are credible alternatives to the dogmatic and one-sided views of certain scientists, if there is no once-and-for-all proven truth, then we have the obligation to at least teach the debate. After all, Gravity is just a theory. And if we teach it at all, we must face our responsibilities to generations. We must, absolutely must, make it clear to our students that this is the case. WE MUST TEACH THE DEBATE.

    • Bob Pease says:

      Thin, dude.

      Anti-Science bullshit is bringing down America.

      It is conceivable that this is really a Commie or Islamic plot to reduce Americans to Clones who go around talking of “Close(SIC)-mindedness ” among Scientists who don’t like to equate goofy conjecture with evidence.

      Evidence?
      Evidence??
      We don’t got to show you no steenkin’ evidence!!

      Bob Pease

  5. Jenny H says:

    Mmmmm.

    Wouldn’t it be Yodists and Ayodists? Why bring theism into a non-belief?

    • Bob Pease says:

      Structurally, the Yodists vs Nodists (Nudists??) argument is the same as

      California Vs. Missouri

      (LaLa Goofiness vs. “Oh yeah?”)

      Eureka!!!.. an Isomorphism !!!

      RJ Pease
      (Chief Twisted Gourd)

    • Diane G. says:

      Beat me to it. That bothered me so much I couldn’t read the article. Where did that “-thei-” come from and why?

  6. sittingbytheriver says:

    funny article!

  7. Sean says:

    I too believe in the Force…Currently we know it by the way it’s divided

    Strong nuclear force
    Weak nuclear force
    Electromagnetism
    Gravity

    And some day we might discover the Grand Unified Theory.

    Fantastic and funny article. Would’ve been great had it come out closer to May the Fourth.

get eSkeptic
our free newsletter

Science in your inbox every Wednesday!

eSkeptic is our free email newsletter, delivered once a week. In it, you’ll receive: fascinating articles, announcements, podcasts, book reviews, and more…


Popular Articles
on skeptic.com

Here are the articles that people have been sharing over the last few days.

Carbon Comic

Carbon Comic (by Kyle Sanders)

Carbon Comic, which appears in Skeptic magazine, is created by Kyle Sanders: a pilot and founder of Little Rock, Arkansas’ Skeptics in The Pub. He is also a cartoonist who authors Carbon Dating: a skeptical comic strip about science, pseudoscience, and relationships. It can be found at carboncomic.com.

Help the
Skeptics Society
at no cost to you!

Planning on shopping at Amazon? By clicking on our Amazon affiliate link, which will open the Amazon Store in your Internet browser, the Skeptics Society will receive a small commission on your purchase. Your prices for all products remain the same, yet you’ll provide essential financial support for the work of the nonprofit Skeptics Society.

amazon.com

See our affiliate links page for Amazon.ca, Amazon.de, Amazon.co.uk, iTunes, and Barnes & Noble links.

FREE PDF Download

Reality Check: How Science Deniers Threaten Our Future (paperback cover)

Who believes them? Why? How can you tell if they’re true?

What is a conspiracy theory, why do people believe in them, and why do they tend to proliferate? Why does belief in one conspiracy correlate to belief in others? What are the triggers of belief, and how does group identity factor into it? How can one tell the difference between a true conspiracy and a false one?

FREE PDF Download

The Science Behind Why People See Ghosts

The Science Behind Why People See Ghosts

Do you know someone who has had a mind altering experience? If so, you know how compelling they can be. They are one of the foundations of widespread belief in the paranormal. But as skeptics are well aware, accepting them as reality can be dangerous…

FREE PDF Download

Top 10 Myths About Evolution

Top 10 Myths About Evolution (and how we know it really happened)

If humans came from apes, why aren’t apes evolving into humans? Find out in this pamphlet!

FREE PDF Download

Top 10 Things You Should Know About Alternative Medicine

Top 10 Things You Should Know About Alternative Medicine

Topics include: chiropractic, the placebo effect, homeopathy, acupuncture, and the questionable benefits of organic food, detoxification, and ‘natural’ remedies.

FREE PDF Download

Learn to be a Psychic in 10 Easy Lessons

Learn to do Psychic “Cold Reading” in 10
Easy Lessons

Psychic readings and fortunetelling are an ancient art — a combination of acting and psychological manipulation.

Copyright © 1992–2014 Skeptic and its contributors. For general enquiries regarding the Skeptics Society or Skeptic magazine, email skepticssociety@skeptic.com or call 1-626-794-3119. Website-related matters: webmaster@skeptic.com. Enquiries about online store orders: orders@skeptic.com. To update your subscription address: subscriptions@skeptic.com. See our Contact Information page for more details. This website uses Google Analytics, Google AdWords, and AddThis tracking software.