Skeptic: Examining Extraordinary Claims and Promoting Science Skeptic: Examining Extraordinary Claims and Promoting Science

top navigation:

Wednesday, March 21st, 2012 | ISSN 1556-5696

eSkeptic: the email newsletter of the Skeptics Society

Share this eSkeptic with friends online. Subscribe | Donate | Watch Lectures | Shop


A 3-Day Workshop with Michael Shermer at the Esalen Institute in Bog Sur, Califronia. June 1-3, 2012. Register online at Esalen.org.

A 3-Day Workshop with Michael Shermer
presented by the Esalen Institute, Big Sur, CA
June 1–3, 2012

JOIN MICHAEL SHERMER for a 3-day workshop in one of the most beautiful locations on the planet: the Esalen Institute in Big Sur, California, situated on “120 acres of fertile land carved out between mountain and ocean” (located right on Pacific Coast Highway overlooking the crashing waves of the Pacific Ocean below).

Between workshops, there is plenty to do at Esalen. Experience magnificent hiking in the local mountains, or join Michael Shermer for a wonderful cycling trip up and down the coast. Visit the Arts Center, stroll through the beautiful farm and gardens or get your feet wet at the easily accessible beach. Tempt your taste buds with delicious, healthy food, and pamper yourself with a relaxing massage (which, according to Michael, is the best he’s ever had)! Join in the post-workshop discussion and a soak in the waters of the centuries-old natural hot spring that gushes out of the cliffside at 119 degrees (80 gallons/minute) and flows into a hot tub perched 50 feet above the Pacific Ocean!

“Esalen is one of the finest resort spas I’ve ever seen—well worth experiencing even if there was no workshop at all! This is a weekend adventure you won’t want to miss!”

—Michael Shermer

Experience Esalen (click an image to enlarge it)
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute

Click any photo to enlarge. Then, click the left or right side of the enlarged photo to view other photos. All photos copyright © 2012 Esalen Institute, used with permission.

REGISTER FOR THIS WORKSHOP

Workshop Schedule

Each of the five 2-hour sessions will consist of a 90-minute lecture followed by 30 minutes of Q&A and audience discussion. Please note that there is plenty of “down time” between sessions for additional discussions over meals (and hot tubs)!

FRIDAY, JUNE 1, 8:30 PM –10:30 PM
The Believing Brain: From Ghosts and Gods to Politics and Conspiracies—How We Construct Beliefs and Reinforce Them as Truths
SATURDAY, JUNE 2, 9:30 AM–1:00 PM
Why Darwin Matters: Science and Religion in Evolution; Why People Believe in God
LATER ON SATURDAY, JUNE 2, 7:15 PM–10:15 PM
The Science of Good and Evil: Why People Cheat, Gossip, Care, share, and Follow the Golden Rule
SUNDAY, JUNE 3, 9:30 AM –11:30 AM
The Moral Arc of Science: How Science and Reason Have Bent the Arc of the Moral Universe Toward Truth, Justice, Freedom & Prosperity
Esalen Meals and Times

The food at the Esalen Institute is magnificent and healthy. And it’s very social seating so we can all hang out together during meals as well as the workshop discussions.

BREAKFAST: 8:30 am – 9:45 am
LUNCH: 12:30 pm – 1:45 pm  (SUNDAY BRUNCH 12:15 pm – 1:30 pm)
DINNER: 6:00 pm – 7:30 pm

Weekend Fees (including workshop)

The price for the weekend depends on the room selection: a Standard room is $730; a Premium room is $1210. Price includes all meals. Esalen requests a $150 deposit to reserve your place. Balance of payment is due five days before the workshop begins. Reservations must be made through the Esalen Institute, not through the Skeptics Society or Michael Shermer. At these prices (including the workshop) your weekend will probably cost less than the resorts and spas at expensive hotels up and down the coast.

This is not a Skeptics Society event. The Skeptics Society is not sponsoring this event, nor do we profit from it.

REGISTER FOR THIS WORKSHOP

Contact
Esalen Institute
Work 55,000 Highway 1 , Big Sur, California, 93920, United States

(programs)
(general mailbox)

Programs 1-831-667-3038 (programs)
Reservations 1-831-667-3005 (reservations)
Fax 1-831-667-0329 (fax)
About Michael Shermer
photo copyright 2012 Esalen Institute

DR. MICHAEL SHERMER is the Founding Publisher of Skeptic magazine and editor of Skeptic.com, a monthly columnist for Scientific American, and an Adjunct Professor at Claremont Graduate University. Dr. Shermer’s latest book is The Believing Brain: From Ghosts and Gods to Politics and Conspiracies—How We Construct Beliefs and Reinforce Then as Truths. Dr. Shermer’s previous book is The Mind of the Market, on evolutionary economics, and prior to that he released Why Darwin Matters. He is the author of The Science of Good and Evil and of Why People Believe Weird Things. Dr. Shermer received his B.A. in psychology from Pepperdine University, M.A. in experimental psychology from California State University, Fullerton, and his Ph.D. in the history of science from Claremont Graduate University (1991). He was a college professor for 20 years, and since his creation of Skeptic magazine he has appeared on such shows as The Colbert Report, 20/20, Dateline, Charlie Rose, Oprah, Leeza, Unsolved Mysteries, and Larry King Live. He has also done interviews in countless documentaries aired on PBS, A&E, Discovery, The History Channel, The Science Channel, and The Learning Channel. Check out Michael Shermer’s page at Shop Skeptic.


About this week’s eSkeptic

In this week’s eSkeptic, Tina Dupuy examines the history of straw men inherent in anti-abortion and other vilification campaigns. Dupuy is an award-winning writer, investigative journalist, and managing editor of Crooks and Liars. Tina appears frequently on MSNBC, Current TV, RT and BBC and all over the radio frequencies via KCRW’s To The Point, The Stephanie Miller Show, The Block Radio and The Leslie Marshall Show. She writes for Los Angeles Times, The Atlantic, Fast Company, Alternet, LA Weekly and Newsday among many others. Her weekly op-ed column is nationally syndicated through Cagle Cartoons.

Share this eSkeptic with friends online. Click the + for more options.
Subscribe to Skeptic magazine for more great articles like this one.

illustration copyright 2012 Pat Linse

Fetus Food
Another Urban Legend Busted

by Tina Dupuy

Freshman Oklahoma state senator Ralph Shortey recently introduced a bill that would ban “the sale or manufacture of food or products which contain aborted human fetuses.” After a collective brow-raise over such a bizarre proposal, Shortey told the Los Angeles Times he got the idea “while doing some research on the Internet.”

So is there an issue with aborted fetuses ending up as foodstuffs? No. And there never has been.

Shortey’s bill is a wild overstatement of the latest front in the anti-abortion fight, one being prosecuted on an obscure Oklahoma anti-abortion website that has been trying to organizing a campaign to boycott PepsiCo because of a research contract it has with a company called Senomyx for beverage sweetener research that the anti-abortion activist charge involves using the HEK-293 cell line in laboratory tests. HEK-293 is a cell line developed in Holland in the early 1970s through the fusion of a kidney cell from an aborted fetus and a virus that immortalized the cells, or allowed them to keep replicating in a laboratory. “Senomyx does not provide ingredients to PepsiCo, nor do they manufacture PepsiCo products. Our work with Senomyx is focused on beverage sweetener research to help us reduce sugar in future global products,” according to Pepsi.

But solving a problem is not the real goal of proposing a ban.

Shortey’s bill sits squarely in a tradition of vilification that’s existed longer than English, mass media, or even Christianity. It’s the timeless Blood Libel: the blood drinking straw man who’s been given different titles over the millennia. Not only do abortionists kill babies, the bill implies, they want us all to commit the most culturally repulsive of all offenses—cannibalism.

The first recorded Blood Libel is from 31 AD. It’s told by two Jewish historians, who lived in the first century in then-Roman Alexandria, Egypt: Philo, in his account of Flaccus the Lieutenant-Governor of Egypt; and Flavius Josephus, in his work, “Against Apion.”

Here’s what these sources tell us: Apion was a skilled hyperbolist and Lieutenant-Governor Flaccus was a desperate politician who tried to avert Caligula’s wrath.

Around 30 AD, Apion, a Graeco-Egyptian grammarian and writer, had spent a great deal of time spreading nasty snipes about the Jewish citizens of Alexandria. His motives for this pastime have been lost to history, but Apion claimed Jews worshiped weird gods and refused to have images of the emperor in their temples. Oh, and to make this all worse, he whispered to many a curious audience that the Jews had been led out of Egypt because they were lepers.

Apion created a narrative. He wrote that it was a part of Jewish law to kidnap a Greek once a year and fatten him up and taste his entrails. Jews were cannibals

Lieutenant-Governor Flaccus used the suspicions about the Jews as a wedge to curry favor with the new emperor. Since the Jews of Alexandria were against Caligula, Flaccus appointed himself as the guy to remedy the problem.

Thousands of Alexandrian Jews—men, women and children—were tortured and killed as a direct result of Apion’s defamations, a pioneering set of slanders that have proved to have real staying power.

Propaganda depends on things sounding vaguely familiar, lending a veneer of credibility to false claims. This is also why repetition is a popular tactic to sway public opinion—the creation of familiarity, which is then mistaken for truth. The Jews are not the only group to have suffered from slander campaigns; they also have been waged against alleged witches, gypsies and many other outsiders, often with equally dire consequences.

In the 19th century, Catholics were a popular target of sharp and false tongues in the U.S. The most widely read book of that century here was Uncle Tom’s Cabin. Also widely read was a memoir by a woman calling herself Maria Monk titled, Awful Disclosures of Maria Monk: or, The Hidden Secrets of a Nun’s Life in a Convent Exposed, published in 1836. The book claimed to be the first-hand account of a former nun in a Quebec convent, and to provide an insider’s view of Catholics. One of her claims was that there were libraries packed full of books and not one bible. Another allegation: Not only were the priests having sex with the nuns, the unsuspecting narrator had stumbled upon a room where the convent kept baby corpses. Yes, the Catholics, who already ceremonially drink the blood of their Savior, also were killers of babies. Piles of them. Because that way the illegitimate but baptized infants would ascend to heaven more rapidly—without any further sinning.

The book was a sensation—perhaps the most widely read book in America before Uncle Tom’s Cabin was published, according to Richard J. Hofstadter’s seminal 1964 essay, “The Paranoid Style in American Politics.” And its tale was, of course, false. Even basic facts about the convent where “Monk” claimed to live were not true. The book was totally debunked—but not before it had burrowed into the popular imagination. Most of the century’s immigrants, the 19th century underclass, were from Catholic countries, and any justification for scorning them was welcomed. The Nativist movement and the Know-Nothings thrived on anti-Catholic sentiment. And remember, the Klu Klux Klan was not just terrorizing black people in the south—they were also terrorizing Catholics.

An example closer to our own time was the Satanic Panic of the 1980s. That decade saw widespread allegations of very specific type of Satanic cult conspiracy which, in retrospect, had all the elements of a classic Blood Libel. On a 1988 ABC special, the channel’s then-resident schlock hawk, Geraldo Rivera, did his utmost to enlighten the general public about something evangelicals had held true for years. “Estimates are that there are over one million Satanists in this country,” Rivera declared in prime time. “The majority of them are linked in a highly organized, very secretive network. From small towns to large cities, they have attracted police and FBI attention to their Satanic ritual child abuse, child pornography and grisly Satanic murders. The odds are that this is happening in your town!”

The Satanic Panic was a whiplash from the cultural revolution of the 1970s, a cultural spasm that oddly united therapists and evangelicals. The Christian community had some self-proclaimed former Satanic Priests in their ranks dishing about all the children’s blood they used to drink and the therapists had some new and “innovative” (read: questionable) ways to “recover memories” of being the victims of the Satanic conspiracy. Both schools took over a decade or two to completely discredit.

A 1989 study by the Committee for the Scientific Examination of Religion published in the book Satanism in America: How the Devil Got Much More than his Due by Shawn Carlson, Gerald LaRue and others reported there were 33 organizations and 90 individuals who were actively promoting the Satanism scare. This was a conspiracy all right—just not the one depicted on talk shows with depressed-looking teenagers. Nevertheless, these Satan experts were not only on news programs and at conventions—they were teaching law enforcement seminars on how to spot and investigate Satanic crimes.

The Satanic Panic was barely mentioned in the recent release of the West Memphis Three, the three now thirty-somethings who have spent nearly 20 years in prison for little more than wearing black clothes in a small southern town in 1993. Three 8-year-old boys were murdered in May of that year. And because Jessie Misskelley, 17, Jason Baldwin, 16, and Damien Echols, 18, fit the profile of what was thought at the time to be a Satanist (as in someone who killed children for sport and listened to heavy metal), they were railroaded, found guilty and sentenced to life. Echols was sentenced to death. It took two decades and dozens of celebrities to get them out of jail. Blood libels are far reaching.

The point of rehearsing these historical episodes is this: When a junior senator from the same state that banned Sharia Law proposes to ban feeding Oklahomans aborted baby fetuses, it’s not just some wacky guy in a square state being eccentric.

There is a long and storied global history of demonizing groups of people with whom you disagree by tarring them with the charge of cannibalism—tapping into one of humanity’s deepest and most firmly held taboos. The consequences of such charges have often been deadly. Abortion service providers are already routinely harassed, threatened, shot at and even bombed. Casting them now as handmaidens to cannibalism is just the next extreme step in turning the decades-long effort to make them into pariahs.

Skeptical perspectives on urban legends & critical thinking…
cover Urban Legends
by Dr. Jan Harold Brunvand

Dr. Brunvand, the world’s leading scholar of urban legends and myths, shows how and why we have all fallen for such stories as alligators in the sewers, fake warnings, humor, sex and horror stories. All share one thing in common—they are too good to be true. Learn to spot an Urban Legend from the King of Urban Legends himself. Witty, wise, and enjoyable.
ORDER THE DVD

cover Why People Believe Weird Things: Pseudoscience, Superstition, and Other Confusions of Our Time
by Michael Shermer

In this age of supposed scientific enlightenment, many people still believe in mind reading, past-life regression theory, New Age hokum, and alien abduction. In this no-holds-barred assault on popular superstitions and prejudices, Shermer debunks these nonsensical claims and explores the very human reasons people find otherworldly phenomena, conspiracy theories, and cults so appealing. Shermer takes on science luminaries like physicist Frank Tippler and others, who hide their spiritual beliefs behind the trappings of science.
ORDER THE BOOK

cover Genius: Myth and Reality
Skeptic magazine volume 2, number 1

Inclues a special section on The Amadeus Myth; Muses on the Mental Miracles of Genius by Michael Shermer; Genius by James Randi; In Search of Genius by James Gleick; PLUS: Mathemagics: How to Look Like a Genius Without Really Trying by Arthur Benjamin; A review essay of Genius: The Life and Science of Richard Feynman by Milton Rothman; The “Science” of Noah’s Ark by Denton Porter; The Great Hungarian Crop Circle by Gyula Bencze and James Randi; more… ORDER THE BACK ISSUE

cover The Demon-Haunted World:
Science as a Candle in the Dark

by Carl Sagan

The great astronomer and science writer, Carl Sagan, challenges New Agers and explains social phenomena like UFOs, alien abductions, recovered memories, satanic cults, witch crazes, hallucinations, and how to detect baloney. This is Sagan’s most popular book among skeptics, filled with quotable maxims, popular among college professors as a supplemental text for students, but a classic for everyone who cares about living in a sane and safe world without superstition.
ORDER THE CRITICAL THINKING CLASSIC

10 Comments »

10 Comments

  1. Ricky says:

    I thought the “Fetus Food” story was going to be about Ultra Veal.

    http://www.amazon.com/review/RR2H50O1MI5OC

  2. James Conrad says:

    BUT if this company is successful in making a sugar substitute wouldn’t that mean that fetus (DNA) would be sold as food?

    • julie says:

      No – not if they don’t use the HEK-293 cell line for anything but research on how human taste receptors work in relation to sweetness. Is it clear that this is the case?

      So boycott Pepsi on ethical grounds about your perceptions of what the dignity of human life is all about – but don’t go joining in this blood libel about the company.

      Their products are an unhealthy affront to human dignity, regardless – I have been “boycotting” them for decades.

  3. Pope Bobby II says:

    Two different issues have been expialidociously supercalifragilated here

    1. Whether or not fetuses are human and have corresponding civil liberties.

    2. Whether it is ok to eat products which are manufactured frorm products containing DNA . obtained from human stem cells.

    The Church of the Subgenuis ( 69th Clench)
    takes no stand on issue 1 but does think the question is not well enough defined .

    We consider issue 2 as moot ( meaning still open to argument)

    Soyelnt Green, anyone?

    RJP

  4. Pope Bobby II says:

    just as an aside,
    Catholic bashing is alive and well in “intellectual” and ” liberal ” sectors
    as well as in hayseeds, fundies and KKKrackers

    Remember that KKK claimed that it could mean the ” enemy”
    K**ns
    Kikes
    Katholics

    Lately replaced with your choice of
    Kommies or Kweers

    Tread lightly …

    RJP

  5. Gina says:

    The part about no bibles in the libraries is probably the truth: I don’t know if this has changed but when I was a child, as a catholic in Quebec we were not allowed to read the bible. I didn’t care, so I never asked why.

    • Pope Bobby II says:

      Congratulations on living to 176 !!!

      In the 20th Century the Douay Rhiems was until recently ENCOURAGED to be read by all US catholics and indulgences were offered for reading the Bible
      It actually was written in ENGLISH instead of Shakespeare lingo and I still like it better than the thee-thou KJV

      Nowadays many editions are permitted .
      There may have been some Radical Fundo-Catholics in Quebec some years ago, but the “NO Bibles in libraries” jazz sure sounds like Urban Myth to me!!

      RJP

  6. Mister Bill says:

    I’d like to comment that straw man tactics not unique to the anti abortion side of this issue. Whenever a Muslim acts out violently, anywhere in the world, we are inundated with stern notices that Islam is not monolithic, most Muslims don’t feel that way, etc.

    But on the other hand, whenever some whack job bombs a clinic or shoots a doctor, it is portrayed as if every soul who finds abortion distasteful is either openly with the shooter or cheering him on covertly.

    I take a dim view of the widespread practice of abortion, for reasons both ethical and social. I do not advocate violence over the matter, nor do I see outlawing the practice as a practical solution. I assure you I have enlightened views where women are concerned, and I most certainly have never heard of the “eating fetus” clowns discussed in this article.

    Like the vast majority of those who respectfully oppose the practice of abortion, I’d like to at least get the benefit of the doubt that is given to Muslims when terrorism rears its head.

  7. Robbie says:

    Can’t understand why sceptic writers think we should believe and agree with their opinions.As a sceptic,surely you can be anti abortion,not in favor of homosexuality,and not necessarily in agreement with the causes of global warming.The true sceptic has an inquiring mind and needn’t be swayed by other sceptics,or what often appears to be required beliefs.This doesn’t imply open opposition to any of the above beliefs,or intolerance,but we all have a right to our own opinions

get eSkeptic
our free newsletter

Science in your inbox every Wednesday!

eSkeptic is our free email newsletter, delivered once a week. In it, you’ll receive: fascinating articles, announcements, podcasts, book reviews, and more…


Popular Articles
on skeptic.com

Here are the articles that people have been sharing over the last few days.

Carbon Comic

Carbon Comic (by Kyle Sanders)

Carbon Comic, which appears in Skeptic magazine, is created by Kyle Sanders: a pilot and founder of Little Rock, Arkansas’ Skeptics in The Pub. He is also a cartoonist who authors Carbon Dating: a skeptical comic strip about science, pseudoscience, and relationships. It can be found at carboncomic.com.

Help the
Skeptics Society
at no cost to you!

Planning on shopping at Amazon? By clicking on our Amazon affiliate link, which will open the Amazon Store in your Internet browser, the Skeptics Society will receive a small commission on your purchase. Your prices for all products remain the same, yet you’ll provide essential financial support for the work of the nonprofit Skeptics Society.

amazon.com

See our affiliate links page for Amazon.ca, Amazon.de, Amazon.co.uk, and iTunes links.

FREE PDF Download

Reality Check: How Science Deniers Threaten Our Future (paperback cover)

Who believes them? Why? How can you tell if they’re true?

What is a conspiracy theory, why do people believe in them, and why do they tend to proliferate? Why does belief in one conspiracy correlate to belief in others? What are the triggers of belief, and how does group identity factor into it? How can one tell the difference between a true conspiracy and a false one?

FREE PDF Download

The Science Behind Why People See Ghosts

The Science Behind Why People See Ghosts

Do you know someone who has had a mind altering experience? If so, you know how compelling they can be. They are one of the foundations of widespread belief in the paranormal. But as skeptics are well aware, accepting them as reality can be dangerous…

FREE PDF Download

Top 10 Myths About Evolution

Top 10 Myths About Evolution (and how we know it really happened)

If humans came from apes, why aren’t apes evolving into humans? Find out in this pamphlet!

FREE PDF Download

Top 10 Things You Should Know About Alternative Medicine

Top 10 Things You Should Know About Alternative Medicine

Topics include: chiropractic, the placebo effect, homeopathy, acupuncture, and the questionable benefits of organic food, detoxification, and ‘natural’ remedies.

FREE PDF Download

Learn to be a Psychic in 10 Easy Lessons

Learn to do Psychic “Cold Reading” in 10
Easy Lessons

Psychic readings and fortunetelling are an ancient art — a combination of acting and psychological manipulation.

Copyright © 1992–2014 Skeptic and its contributors. For general enquiries regarding the Skeptics Society or Skeptic magazine, email skepticssociety@skeptic.com or call 1-626-794-3119. Website-related matters: webmaster@skeptic.com. Enquiries about online store orders: orders@skeptic.com. To update your subscription address: subscriptions@skeptic.com. See our Contact Information page for more details. This website uses Google Analytics, Google AdWords, and AddThis tracking software.