The Skeptics Society & Skeptic magazine


Psychological Risks with COVID-19 Vaccines

Reports about allergic reactions to COVID-19 vaccines will undoubtedly cause anxiety in people. Robert E. Bartholomew & Kate MacKrill remind us that, if history is a guide — and given the large number of people to be vaccinated — a mass anxiety event is not improbable.

The news media have an important role to play in the current race to vaccinate enough people in the United States and around the world, so that we can reach the all-important goal of attaining herd immunity — the key threshold whereby a sufficient number of people have been inoculated and are immune to infection. When that tipping point is reached, person to person infection is expected to become much less likely. By current projections, American immunologist Dr. Anthony Fauci projects that the United States could reach the early stages of herd immunity by late March, 2021.1 The biggest impediment to attaining it is what the World Health Organization describes as “vaccine hesitancy” — the reluctance of people to get vaccinated. Even before the pandemic, the WHO was warning that vaccine hesitancy was a significant threat to world health.2

A major problem in maintaining public confidence in the safety of the vaccines that are being rolled out are reports of allergic reactions in health care workers shortly after being inoculated. The first reports appeared in England and involved two persons with a history of allergic reactions. More recently, two patients in Alaska were affected and more can be expected. Health authorities have been quick to point out that none of these cases were life-threatening.

These incidents will undoubtedly give some people pause in whether or not to take the vaccine. Now there are reports that four people in the Pfizer-BioNTech trial and three in the Moderna trial developed temporary facial paralysis or weakness. Known as Bell’s palsy, the condition is more common than many people think and it’s usually not serious, although it may take several weeks or in rare cases, months to resolve. Exposure to viruses are known to be a trigger, as the nerve that controls muscle contractions on one side of the face becomes inflamed.3

It is well-known within the medical community that during mass inoculation campaigns, you can expect to see a relatively small number of individual anxiety reactions in nervous patients. Common symptoms include fainting, dizziness, nausea, and breathlessness. What is less known is the likelihood of a collective anxiety event. Most commonly referred to as mass psychogenic illness, outbreaks during immunization campaigns are well-known. Since 1992, there have been no less than 12 major episodes that have been written up in medical journals.

If an event were to occur, the media needs to react with caution and avoid sensational headlines and reporting. This could prove to be challenging because the news media is driven by a business model that thrives on clicks and views. If it bleeds, it leads. Another problem facing authorities will be the historical reaction to similar outbreaks, which are usually met with anger and disbelief. In today’s social media age, a single psychogenic outbreak could quickly undermine global confidence in the safety of different COVID-19 vaccines.

Outbreaks of mass psychogenic illness are often dramatic and can have lasting ramifications. In May 2007, 720 girls attending a school in Melbourne, Australia, received the first of three inoculations for the Human papillomavirus (HPV). Two hours later, 26 of the girls were seen by the school nurse for an array of complaints including nausea, headache, dizziness, heart palpitations, muscle weakness, hyperventilation, and fainting. Four were rushed to a nearby children’s hospital where they quickly recovered.4

The impact of the event was swift even though the psychological nature was quickly determined. Firstly, in response to the news of a “mystery illness,” the share market value of the firm making the vaccine lost nearly $1 billion dollars (AUS).5 Secondly, the event triggered a flurry of negative media reports questioning the safety of the vaccine and eroding public confidence. As a commentary in The Age (Melbourne) newspaper asked: “Why are we experimenting with drugs on girls?”6 Similar clusters of psychogenic illness have resulted in significant declines in girls lining up to receive the HPV vaccine and placing them at undue risk for cervical cancer.7

The rush to create a safe and effective vaccine to counter COVID-19 in less than a year is nothing short of miraculous. It would be a shame if efforts to reach herd immunity were to be undermined by a phenomenon that has been well documented by social scientists and continues to foster controversy — mostly due to the sigma that is attached to it. END

About the Authors

Robert E. Bartholomew is an Honorary Senior Lecturer in the Department of Psychological Medicine at the University of Auckland in New Zealand. He has written numerous books on the margins of science covering UFOs, haunted houses, Bigfoot, lake monsters — all from a perspective of mainstream science. He has lived with the Malay people in Malaysia, and Aborigines in Central Australia. He is the co-author of 2 seminal books: Outbreak! The Encyclopedia of Extraordinary Social Behavior with Hilary Evans (Anomalist Books, 2009), and Havana Syndrome with Robert W. Baloh (Copernicus Books, 2020).

Kate MacKrill is a doctoral student in Health Psychology at Auckland University. Her PhD. thesis examines the power of the nocebo effect.

References
  1. Booker, Brakkton. 2020. “Fauci Predicts U.S. Could See Signs Of Herd Immunity By Late March Or Early April.” National Public Radio, December 15.
  2. World Health Organization. 2019. “Ten Threats to Global Health in 2019.” https://bit.ly/2WqGuQU
  3. Rodriguez, Adrianna. 2020. “COVID-19 Vaccine Trials Report Cases of Brief Facial Paralysis. That’s not as Scary as it Sounds.” USA Today, December 15.
  4. Buttery, Jim, Simon Madin, Nibel Crawford, Sonja Elia, Sophie La Vincente, Sarah Hanieh, Lindsay Smith, and Bruce Bolam. 2008. “Mass Psychogenic Response to Human Papillomavirus Vaccination.” Medical Journal of Australia; 189: 261–262.
  5. Chapman S, MacKenzie R. 2007. “Fainting schoolgirls 5 wipe $A1bn off market value of Gardasil producer.” British Medical Journal; 334: 1195.
  6. Reist, Melinda and Renate Klein. 2007. “Why are we Experimenting with Drugs on Girls?” The Age, May 25.
  7. Simas, Clarissa, Nubia Munoz, Leonardo Arregoces, and Heidi Larson. 2019. “HPV Vaccine Confidence and Cases of Mass Psychogenic Illness following Immunization in Carmen de Bolivar, Colombia.” Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics; 15(1): 163–166.

This article was published on December 21, 2020.

 

8 responses to “Psychological Risks with COVID-19 Vaccines”

  1. Tzindaro says:

    The symptom-pattern being labeled “covid 19” may or may not be a distinct disease, and if it is, it may or may not be caused by a virus, and if it is, it may or may not be spread via contagion from one person to another. There are competing hypotheses on each of those points.

    But there is plenty of solid data to show that this disease-picture is not a serious danger to anyone in reasonably good health. The risk to a healthy person with no previously existing medical or lifestyle factors that compromise immunity is as close to zero as it could possibly get.

    It follows that for a healthy person to submit to a vaccination with any degree of risk is adding to that persons’ risk, not decreasing it.

    As for the concept of “herd immunity”, it is my responsibility to take care of my health. It is not my job to take care of other peoples’ health. That is their responsibility, not mine. I will not be taking any vaccine for a disease that is not a danger to me.

    • Edward Latimer-Sayer BSc MBBS FRCS retired doctor says:

      Well, I’m glad you don’t live in my community, because it is undoubtedly the responsibility of a good citizen not to do anything which endangers the health of others. This includes not going around spreading disease such as tuberculosis or AIDS or syphilis and spouting claptrap about COVID-19. Do your duty as a member of society and get vaccinated and help protect us all.

      • George Tzindaro says:

        If I do not agree with the orthodox, officially-designated narative, it is not my duty to pretend I do or act against my own best interest in doing something I think is misguided and ineffective. It is my dutry as a good citizen to speak up and say what I think is the correct thing to say.

        In my opinion, it is you, and the official government anointed “experts” who are spouting claptrap and I am teaching the true facts about this largely harmless disease and I am not going to stop just because someone ignorant of what I consider to be the facts tells me to.

        Your authoritarian attitude is exactly why I refuse to be vaccinated. I am doing my duty by explaining to anyone who will listen that they should not submit to vaccination.

  2. Randy says:

    Psychogenic illnesses are real, but adverse reactions to vaccines are also real. It’ll likely take more data to sift out psychological responses from physiological responses—and both are related—they can influence each other. And, those with either will likely have factors in common that may eventually be identified. Data from the trials are fairly robust, and these vaccines have received “emergency use authorization,” but data from the trials will continue for at least 12-18 more months. Regardless, “just because you’re paranoid doesn’t mean they’re not after you.”

  3. R. Williams says:

    Fauci is a proven liar. When I saw a quote from him, you lost me right there.

    • B.D. Hasegawa says:

      It’s irresponsible to just throw that out. This article is replete with references; what are yours?

  4. B Bricks says:

    Bell’s palsy should not be taken lightly. If one side of the face feels swollen or especially if numb or paralyzed and you are unable to contract the muscles, please take it seriously and contact a doctor. Left untreated, in some cases it can result in permanent paralysis. It is easily treatable with proper medication.

  5. Alice says:

    If our defeat of this virus depends upon the news media doing the right thing, we are all doomed!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how Akismet processes your comment data. Comments are closed 45 days after an article is published.

Donate
For those seeking a sound scientific viewpoint

Newsletter

Be in the know!

Subscribe to eSkeptic: our free email newsletter and get great podcasts, videos, reviews and articles from Skeptic magazine, announcements, and more in your inbox once or twice a week.

Sign me up!

Copyright © 1992–2022. All rights reserved. | P.O. Box 338 | Altadena, CA, 91001 | 1-805-576-9396. The Skeptics Society is a non-profit, member-supported 501(c)(3) organization (ID # 95-4550781) whose mission is to promote science & reason. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Privacy Policy.